Connect with us


Browns 21, Steelers 21: The breakdown — thumbs up, thumbs down, the matchups


T.J. Watt, Steelers linebacker

He’s quickly become a nemesis for the Browns. Just like so many Steelers defenders before him.

Watt, in just his third game in the rivalry, was virtually unstoppable. He had four sacks, eight tackles and blocked Zane Gonzalez’s 43-yard field goal attempt at the end of overtime to preserve the 21-21 tie.


“I got my left hand on that,” Watt said. “I treated it as I was just trying to make a play.”

In his NFL debut last season in the opener in Cleveland, Watt had two sacks and an interception. He also had a sack in the 2017 finale that finished Cleveland’s winless season. He’s the younger brother of Texans superstar J.J.


Tyrod Taylor, Browns quarterback

This is not to pin the loss on Taylor. His protection was nonexistent for much of the game, the conditions were ugly and the play calling didn’t do him many favors. But given repeated chances to win the game at the end of regulation and overtime, he couldn’t deliver.

“Was not able to get the job done,” he said. “The only stat that matters to me is wins and losses.”

That’s good, because the numbers weren’t pretty. He went 15-for-40 (37.5 percent) for 197 yards, seven sacks, a touchdown, an interception and a 51.8 rating. He rushed eight times for a team-high 77 yards.

The franchise’s 29th starting quarterback since 1999 impressed teammates by taking the punishment and keeping them in the game.

“Extremely poised, extremely resilient, getting banged up, taking hits, getting rushed in the pocket, still finding out ways to make his checkdowns, make his reads,” receiver Josh Gordon said. “I’m sure he wishes we could have a bunch of those plays back, but he stayed in there. He’s cool under pressure. He always is and that makes it easier for us to do our jobs.”


Watt didn’t have to stick his hand high to block Gonzalez’s try at a winning field goal. The kick came out low, and didn’t have a chance with Watt and safety Sean Davis pushing left guard Joel Bitonio back toward Gonzalez. Bitonio said the Steelers loaded the left side and were able to get a good push. Coach Hue Jackson and Gonzalez believed the Steelers were offside — Davis got a great jump but on replay it was difficult to tell on replay if he left early.

“We just gotta sit in there,” Bitonio said. “We’ve just got to be better on that field goal on the left side there.”

Gonzalez said the steady rain and soggy field had nothing to do with the miss. He put none of the blame on himself.

“No, that’s not a pulled kick, they broke through and they’re right there, so there’s not much more we could do about it,” he said. “Our job is you look at the spot, you kick it and I felt like I hit a great ball and then when I looked up it was boom-boom situation and it kind of sucks.”



The record since 1999 for teams with a turnover differential of plus-five or better. The Browns have two of the losses and now the tie.


“It was a thriller. It was fun. We fought back and tied it up. That is just a credit to the perseverance and the toughness on this team to not give up.” — Defensive end Myles Garrett, who had two sacks and two forced fumbles.



Tyrod Taylor never got going as he was pressured all day. Josh Gordon’s only catch in three targets was a touchdown. Jarvis Landry had seven catches for 106 yards.

Ben Roethlisberger threw for 335 yards and a touchdown but had three interceptions and lost two fumbles. James Conner rushed for 135 yards and two touchdowns with a fumble. Antonio Brown caught nine passes for 93 yards.

Edge: Steelers


The Browns gave up yardage. They also gave the team a chance by forcing six turnovers. Rookie Denzel Ward started things with a diving interception.

The Steelers sacked Taylor seven times and harassed him throughout. They allowed only seven points off the turnovers.

Edge: Even

Special teams

Zane Gonzalez’s low field goal attempt in overtime was blocked. The coverage units were substandard, allowing a 28-yard kickoff return and a 22-yard punt return by Ryan Switzer. There were too many penalties on the returns, and Jabrill Peppers had a bad fair catch in overtime.

Chris Boswell missed a 42-yard field goal wide left in overtime.

Edge: Steelers


New coordinator Todd Haley’s game plan called for too many passes early and left Taylor vulnerable to the pass rush. The lone sustained drive of the day featured eight straight run calls to open the third quarter and ended in a touchdown. Hue Jackson’s team didn’t quit despite dire circumstances in the fourth quarter.

Pittsburgh took away Josh Gordon and made life difficult on Taylor. Mike Tomlin doesn’t lose to Cleveland.

Edge: Steelers

Browns writer for The Chronicle-Telegram and The Medina Gazette. Proud graduate of Northwestern University. Husband and stepdad. Avid golfer who needs to hit the range to get down to a single-digit handicap. Right about Johnny Manziel, wrong about Brandon Weeden. Contact Scott at 440-329-7253, or email and follow him on and Twitter.


More in Analysis