Connect with us

Analysis

Training Camp Preview, Part 1: Breaking down the QB competition between Shedeur Sanders and Deshaun Watson

Quarterback is the only place to start.

Whether it’s a discussion of the Browns’ chances for the 2026 season, the most unsettled — and arguably most interesting — piece of the team, or the way to kick off the pre-training camp coverage that will lead up to the first practice July 29 in Berea … Deshaun Watson vs. Shedeur Sanders deserves top billing.

Shedeur Sanders thrills young fans at his camp after returning from ‘amazing’ workouts with teammates in Miami

While the subject has been covered thoroughly since new coach Todd Monken announced in the winter he’d hold an open competition between the pair, the impending start of camp feels like the right time to reset the scene.

Advertisement

THE BACKDROP

The Browns haven’t identified a long-term franchise quarterback since Bernie Kosar in the second half of the 1980s.

The failures and instability at the position since the team’s return in 1999 have doomed it to 23 losing seasons and 11 coaches, as 42 quarterbacks have started at least one game. The brief successes — playoff trips in 2002, 2020 and 2023 – were followed by more uncertainty at the position, with each of the starters in those playoff games gone within three years.

CB Damarri Mathis signed as training camp nears

Watson (19 starts with Cleveland) and Sanders (seven starts) have already taken their place on the infamous QB jersey and appear to many as uninspiring options in a league dominated by the best at the position. Their competition, and the season, will proceed with the organization keeping an eye on the quarterbacks expected to be available in the 2027 draft.

THE HOPE

If Sanders, heading into his second season, were to become a franchise quarterback, he would solve the Browns’ biggest problem for a decade. He’s got a legion of diehard fans and has the personality to energize a beaten-down fanbase.

But he’s far from a sure thing.

He slid to the fifth round of the draft and only played as a rookie after Kenny Pickett and Joe Flacco were traded and Dillon Gabriel was injured. Sanders went 3-4 as the starter, showing toughness and big-play ability. He also ranked at or near the bottom of the league with a 56.6 completion percentage, 4.7 interception percentage, 68.1 passer rating and 9.8 sack percentage.

When he’s at his best, accuracy is his biggest strength. His 71.8 completion percentage at Colorado is the all-time FBS record.

He’s not an elite athlete but has an innate ability to escape the pass rush. When he does, he looks to take shots downfield.

On the opposite side of the pros and cons ledger is a tendency to hold the ball too long and take too many negative plays. He needs to be better accepting the easy completions and be willing to throw the ball away and live for another play.

Monken saw improvement during the spring.

“He’s being more decisive,” he said at the end of minicamp. “It just feels like he’s making quicker decisions. The ball’s coming out of his hands, which he’s gonna have to do.”

THE VET

Watson is in full-fledged comeback mode.

He hasn’t played in a game since October 2024, when he sustained the first of two ruptured Achilles tendons. His 2023 season was cut short by surgery to his throwing shoulder. Yet he appeared completely healthy during the offseason program, moving well and throwing with zip.

His biggest edge over Sanders is experience.

Watson has played at an elite level in the NFL, with three Pro Bowls and a league passing title. He’s learned plenty of new systems, so the transition to Monken’s offense is easier for him. He’s also seen every defense.

Of course, Watson’s best football came before he joined the Browns in the disastrous blockbuster trade of 2022. He’s missed 50 games in four years with the Browns, completing 61.2 percent with 19 touchdowns, 12 interceptions and an 80.7 rating. The only reason he’s on the roster, let alone in the competition, is the guaranteed $46 million salary for 2026.

Watson is a better athlete than Sanders and could be a running threat for Monken, who had Lamar Jackson for the last three seasons as coordinator in Baltimore. While Watson can make any throw, inconsistent accuracy continued to be a problem during the offseason. He also holds the ball too long and takes too many sacks.

“He’s excited to play again and to play at a high level,” Monken said. “He plays with his feet. So that’s going to be a huge weapon for him. It has been in his career and as long as he’s healthy it will continue to be a weapon for him.”

THE TIMELINE

The quarterbacks are set to report to camp Thursday with the rookies. The rest of the veterans are due July 28.

Monken wanted to have the starter chosen well before then, but neither Watson nor Sanders separated himself during the offseason. Monken tried to put a positive spin on the situation at the end of minicamp in June.

“I’d love to have it now. We just don’t,” he said. “I think they both can start and play winning football. I’m convinced of it. And I’d say it if I didn’t.

“I mean, I can’t decide now because I think both have earned the opportunity to continue to compete once we put the pads on.”

He said he’ll continue to alternate the first-team reps between Watson and Sanders, with Gabriel and rookie sixth-round pick Taylen Green picking up the scraps. Monken wants to see the whole team in pads — a legitimate pass rush will speed up the clock for the passers — and the quarterbacks in a variety of situations, so a decision likely isn’t coming for a while.

The preseason opener in Chicago on Aug. 15 will be followed by a joint practice with the Bills in Berea on Aug. 20. A decision quickly after that would give the starter three weeks to get ready for the opener Sept. 13 in Jacksonville.

THE GUESS

If the choice were easy, Monken would’ve made it. That means the competition is too close to call.

If it’s still that close when a decision is needed, Sanders should get the nod.

There isn’t a future with Watson. There could be with Sanders. This season could be all about figuring out if he can be the long-term answer, or if a quarterback needs to be drafted in the spring.

But Watson has the chance to push that argument to the backburner. If he clearly outperforms Sanders, the job will be his.

Monken is 60 years old and a head coach in the NFL for the first time. He wants — maybe needs — to win as quickly as possible. The rest of the roster is ready, so a veteran behind center could provide Monken the comfort he seeks.

For Watson to make a legitimate claim for the job, he needs to be more consistent. Too often in OTAs and minicamp a completion would be followed by a pair of misfires.

With no end to the competition in sight, there will be plenty of time to debate the candidates and analyze every throw.

Which is nothing new for the Browns and their fans.

Browns writer for The Chronicle-Telegram and The Medina Gazette. Proud graduate of Northwestern University. Husband and stepdad. Avid golfer who needs to hit the range to get down to a single-digit handicap. Right about Johnny Manziel, wrong about Brandon Weeden. Contact Scott at 440-329-7253, or email and follow him on and Twitter.

Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

More in Analysis